Parser for chemical reactions silently accepts faulty equations

Summary

The parser for chemical reactions accepts chemical reactions with typos, ignores the parts it doesn't understand and the simulations then run with chemical reactions that are different from what the user expects

The two main issues are

punctuation tokens that don't make sense
species that are not in the species list are ignored

Steps to reproduce

Use the tutorial case combustion/fireFoam/LES/simplePMMApanel and edit the file constant/reactions to modify the reaction in

reactions
{
    methaneReaction
    {
        type     irreversibleArrheniusReaction;
        reaction "CH4 + 2O2 = CO2 + 2H2O";
        A        5.2e16;
        beta     0;
        Ta       14906;
    }
}

Possible problems are

        reaction "CH4 + 2O2 = CO2 - 2H2O";

(wrong punctuation token) and

        reaction "CH4 + 2O2 = COO2 + 2H2O";

(unknown species COO2).

What is the current bug behaviour?

The simulation runs without a hint that there is a problem but the used chemical equation is fundamentally different)

What is the expected correct behavior?

Program should crash while reading the faulty equation to give the user a chance to fix it

Environment information

OpenFOAM version : any OF version of the last year. Tested on the current git-version
Operating system :
Hardware info :
Compiler :

Possible fixes

Attached there are 2 patches to fix these problems. One to fail on unknown punctuation tokens. The other one to fail if there is an unknown species (this patch slightly changes the API of the speciesCoeffs-class because for solid reactions when calling the base class the parser should not fail for unknown species because these might be from the "other" phase

0001-Failing-on-extra-punctuation-tokens-in-chemical-equa.patch 0002-Fail-for-unknown-species.patch

Admin message